Embracing Criticism of Your Writing: Turning Feedback into Fuel

Learning to handle criticism constructively can transform your writing and elevate your career.

Let's talk about something we all encounter but rarely enjoy: criticism. As writers, our work is deeply personal, a piece of ourselves we put out into the world. So, when feedback comes our way, especially if it’s harsh or unexpected, it can feel like a personal attack.

But the truth is, handling criticism well is a vital skill that can transform your writing and elevate your career.

First, let’s shift our perspective. Criticism isn’t about you as a person; it’s about the work. This distinction is crucial. When you detach your self-worth from your writing, you can look at feedback more objectively. Remember, even the greatest writers face criticism. Dr. Suess, Louisa May Alcott, Stephen King, and countless other writers received harsh rejections before their work became beloved classics.

So, how do you handle criticism constructively?

Choose Early Readers Carefully

Being selective about who you share your early drafts with and ask for feedback is crucial to your growth as a writer. Early drafts are often raw and unpolished, and sharing them with the wrong audience can result in discouraging, unconstructive criticism that may stifle your creativity and confidence.

Recommended reading: So You Wrote a Thing... Who Cares?

Seek out trusted individuals who understand your vision and can offer constructive, supportive feedback that helps you improve while encouraging your unique voice. The right feedback at this stage can be invaluable, providing insights that refine your work and motivate you to push forward, while the wrong feedback can derail your progress and diminish your enthusiasm.

Listen with an Open Mind

Whether the feedback is from an editor, a peer, or a reader, listen carefully. Resist the urge to defend your work immediately.

Instead, take notes and reflect on what’s being said. Sometimes, our initial reaction is to dismiss criticism, but often, there are nuggets of truth that can help us improve. You don’t have to respond – maybe not right away, and perhaps not at all. It’s important to listen first and decide what the feedback means to you.

Separate Emotion from Analysis & Look for Patterns

It’s natural to feel hurt or defensive, but try to separate these emotions from the analytical part of your brain. Take a break if you need to, and come back to the feedback later. With a clearer head, you’ll be better equipped to see the constructive elements.

If you receive similar feedback from multiple sources, it’s worth paying attention. Patterns in criticism can highlight recurring issues in your writing.

Maybe your characters need more depth, or your plot has pacing issues. Identifying these patterns is the first step toward addressing them. Ask yourself how you can use the feedback to improve your writing.

Consider the Source & Tread Carefully on Social

Navigating social media as a writer can be a double-edged sword. While it's a fantastic platform for sharing your work and connecting with readers, it also exposes you to a wide range of unsolicited criticism, often harsh and unfiltered.

The anonymity and immediacy of social media can bring out the worst in people, leading to comments that are more destructive than constructive. Engaging with criticism on social media requires a thick skin and discernment. It's essential to differentiate between genuine, helpful feedback and comments that are merely negative or trolling.

Recommended reading: Finding Time & Space in Your Life to Write

Responding to constructive criticism with grace and openness can foster positive interactions and growth, but it's equally important to ignore or block toxic comments that add no value. Protect your mental well-being by not taking all feedback to heart, and remember that not every voice on social media has your best interests at heart.

Final Thoughts

Remember why you write. Criticism is just one part of the journey. Your passion for storytelling, your unique voice, and your determination are what truly matter. Keep writing, keep improving, and keep sharing your stories with the world.

Handling criticism isn’t easy, but it’s an essential part of the writer’s life. Embrace it, learn from it, and let it fuel your growth.

Here at The Writers' Den, we support each other through the ups and downs. Share your experiences, lift each other up, and remember that every piece of feedback is a stepping stone on the path to becoming the best writer you can be.